From 5773631f063cdbe16e0880ce21c73cb0b911789c Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Christophe Rhodes Date: Thu, 6 Feb 2014 08:11:59 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] comments and figure from Jan --- els-specializers.org | 67 ++++- figures/dispatch-comparison.pdf | Bin 0 -> 9053 bytes figures/dispatch-comparison.svg | 515 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 3 files changed, 574 insertions(+), 8 deletions(-) create mode 100644 figures/dispatch-comparison.pdf create mode 100644 figures/dispatch-comparison.svg diff --git a/els-specializers.org b/els-specializers.org index 6af1392..d9b66cf 100644 --- a/els-specializers.org +++ b/els-specializers.org @@ -48,6 +48,10 @@ Paepke; AMOP?]. XXX include typical examples of MOP: object persistence; maybe ref. Kizcales "MOPs: why we want them and what else they can do"? (Fig. 2 in that is good) ORMs; sparse slots. + jmoringe: + + introspection, e.g. documentation generation + + programmatic construction of classes and generic functions + e.g. for IDL compilers, model transformations One area of functionality where there is scope for customization by the metaprogrammer is in the mechanics and semantics of method @@ -59,6 +63,8 @@ practice implementation support for this was weak until relatively recently (ref. closer, also check how ContextL and filtered dispatch are implemented). + jmoringe: filtered dispatch uses a custom method combination, i + think Another potential mechanism for customizing dispatch is implicit in the class structure defined by AMOP: standard specializer objects @@ -78,7 +84,12 @@ (ahem) the return value of =class-of=, and allows the metaprogrammer to hook into cacheing schemes to avoid needless recomputation of effective methods for sufficiently similar generic function - arguments. + arguments (See Figure\nbsp\ref{fig:dispatch}). + + #+CAPTION: Dispatch Comparison + #+LABEL: fig:dispatch + #+ATTR_LATEX: width=0.9\linewidth float + [[file:figures/dispatch-comparison.pdf]] The remaining sections in this paper can be read in any order. We give some motivating examples in section XX, including @@ -127,7 +138,7 @@ (defmethod specializer-accepts-p ((s cons-specializer) o) (and (consp o) (eql (car o) (%car s)))) -#| less interesting methods elided |# +#| less interesting methods elided: jmoringe: (un)parsing, specializer + + ))) + `(list ,@(mapcar #'make-parse-form specializer-names))) + #+end_src + for each generic function class. + #+end_quote - [ ] =make-method-lambda= revision (use environment arg?) + + jmoringe: would only be relevant for pattern dispatch, right? I + think, we didn't finish the discussion regarding special + variables vs. environment vs. new protocol function * Related Work - [ ] Newton/Rhodes - [ ] filtered dispatch diff --git a/figures/dispatch-comparison.pdf b/figures/dispatch-comparison.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9a29d1d09cd6acceacc4d358e1d00bd59df73433 GIT binary patch literal 9053 zcma)C1z40#*ERs@5)om=r5kpaU0AxiLqc-tu3Z{IL`pzXN;@pJjKRx#ygjGv~}4u50dLQkRzH0&~OgnW{HRPw{zyAfU6E9lo$I zkVo0l$r@z?grXr$d>|0WBWvq`vUEe24hWQ`w57STg(beIC_WP9W{Ggb_ey)GJLyC% zMDZ}QY?}dKYv?>VnbcL2U!+~Q8dY0F5=NSe?}IyEpxNBiOFPJP^*w1dkzxx?^x?$q zvTCFOTdZ-zb1yz!v+6SAK6bb9kXou7FrORgygoIAJ#0MB$HSXEf#Zi4AY2TC6;lw5yPVz94 z4Ni1hpm8rSJO1+n^R#k}N@fof3QW{c;F<=A{=Y*idj zGZqe>HD8AOwA5)pBDfnn^>;EwSZE30z`Gs8L9ZV4Qd6=pm{upwM|PVM9eVMs;fLT{zM3)H3Cph{ z8*eX==Sf+V&tZ(!)lYwznm+1)y%zWEvy0f>Wz|OYl^bt-IP5;I1l{|xE_%{&{SbDB zQy{tK&R{1CFF{Bc31ELTh}2Fa|55F;qgJF5=<$x#_Xz7HajT$G(-h_~uS?0aw z(%0vf!5oPZwaa{OYUd2yo-tlM^Zn`tXg1s2F$gwzUis;B4J;Yx+I7u}eagUf%kQ9NG&%4~#4R$EWzOL&Y?;ob4&SS5bYkH4?2F=|xzu24x~ zlIFUdofjUvlw##jUF~B5jneN@niKPM*C@CtQy@Eq8J{1hTr>DOy z;QZwWGjN&1beH}@<2o*ey7WXvxhCUG zf)U_bI$8X+)zNR5B!S5cm=c{E1Oy8ZureIV}`AVE~1NF#!7EL4eQ| zAdi#;5DeroN1%VvX$0Ny>z7B?*$MSGX)7)e7YGRZorcgt=)b=P6l#ChXSMCM_;UEFN zf6LJe`o4w~U*3sX`y)N9@2wATHndc7HV|-zg^`lpf>nZ>R5)ehiwemo!YdS{UzfeS zs)8N$K!qZ*6IfwKK}6TN`pU*k%8#O7NyVOtKitgG2`}rlH^r<=0PmxTy_(v~sloHF zcLw^r`vjH_&o2C}=@LlI7(1}SJQuazV(WV7CXkUokO~92FTTq3?zy?CEcw3giF$^~ z_L0`^30JC=JXTH5MOUU_>WuK(D7@rei@@Bv{#)O2qr!*Ds?o5gWuzM;5))}9RLat3tKR&L)$633K{L~%z zqW2cykpTf%&+3u3~5&|r*$UUk;D^sfc?#` zd7yVcaqALdk`!j&z4~CC{Bz{|m%!67$?$Gz350UaQ?f{DGTcWRWgv}w4{8dK;%W=% z+6e@ogRl>{;!cm7K$SeiXi`El*ch5aXj?z#(5rlx-?h@%%4B7yY>CPJ{zBJoG;COvtr&K;u0FhV#gH)6|q1k@?`&hu}ij#cnUJyG5+Qp-Ge@!x4uOW8=-Kf8(rnwZF>6d#O21Y2HD6x9`w7He8xYF4kkP5<)kjh;MtcT`IZ zX_YBhWlvfON5VO6c}JRrH}#dstDuCBuvhQeE0|yDklCM0SQ?etWcPd@jt@1Ali?XR zm)(n-T+QpX&!dR}HOJtzR(ykiFU)WZcV%V=awNR;`4$Wm(Y`(S_08 z<%n|Ea@+Fpc_w3OmOaP;WS>~2A|LJ(y8m=@L1B;iWR6@hk|~cIsSu{JuPpKLjyp3* z3RkZM9|ET%HzZ}MC&FV3*AE}L89^R#lb>0KxrSNx{5BCw++;N%)J7< zgLh}>O)pSWefiG$Nq&BC>%@+4eyKjMIa23*bIYH9e~M*SZK2eV-#)Ra683REjPDtsGxi!v%I{A({3P7+5S(XrIS>met*HnFO^_S67H zSQmMW-P40&@Z+2j?CR>EX-;7|L7~B0O>BgI8y&Yzw0ftX*`-&o^CW%Q+1e@X%?+@t zbIrc0bo*g&`j>W#oI&}s9PXHJd&%#KC@Xmkb?r48nKH69sw)aMU3l?A!$^ZHemt_c zM;84iqakdbJvICb|CEEAW2RlKL4q>V%`D+tlz%XyHdm>rGxvJJ7$Lzb-1vSDk5qh|sMIaPWS6l}+tuZeJ~ zR(0;#EZ4~df2o-VWI)&2N1JQ#SB`^uDGfyvj>Nm37M*>K7m98+=Xfw#>wI5QvSF3u zy1Hoq;#QdO_3Nqx@g?OX=BDY|cF?S@mz0(-EEy#SV|>n()(-rM)_HlgNSbCpf?Afg z*$&EEN3(`QpX70%z+Cgiom_DLv*CeZO`X<&cUjqP{YQ>MqLglYAG4$*#CAWbIls(E zW90ZI8DPluKv7bM=6(R79Jb7=Bb~*YhtfG;rxQL0wV&m!`m^u7wa~4w&n_O$m7H-r zl|vA@6g(bQ$K$%_JkqV45p-XDy{_9SR_FWR#wAvE(B^EqS!ZBQj{VZ0iIQT`(}--T z!r+PJmwHj9*lPs#zs=DH%fKAjZ`xvDAR#ymUy;9WDb6vRPBr zBw@4X+#EVl216*uMeHOl4k2{|q4n3nENXZSg8uZ{>jm(N;%sf}t%Bs|ht>6E)bXFq zl-=U{9wmWpb6wX>vGBcL=#ijr9P?R*fKhRUB~K2n;`W9*BXwe}q5T#9qFF={dGlQF zHk%;0h9GgI-Q_-XD(Ygc;jG-$p!-t2$MZ)pitFLJOi`x6$EL*E?J^tI>T}c<)5-gc zXRpFZMqcl+oj|7qede9>m$na&<<876noM?iMqlVX@u|9bn+>;}>;^1BzBtAFo@KR_ z59h1Tl+dyWHvz03x>(o8{etw01o!rFbBy-*dX{y6^i#_07q@eI1~v?zXEl84uau|k zC$9wPbAOi0q|XID8DK)L7$Qo|OM4%QhZY^!*5%obPu@+~Pd(W;(>RsbJ!U|v4kjPZ zsvWENr!v==JQ)2&+fXTrg87Xf9v z^_Rv=Dk6en3Ez)e=+4yFo?S|;nWS%3p4og6me-1MGE{RAnEOg$cBa8{I?G1p`b`Sgk&Q~kt*AoxySD5m81klZ&WkGDL0TzEE^XY#1kWd+y28r66oZuVO?1f|t3&?bYj=CVxgeh{u(KR-A) zOuE}gh<})2>mZD*uh>yLW4|1}d#;l?-8JKnS|n6{82A+RF*4r7GQKsi zK!~<_Kz?mqg7+kT3Q8+tpCfh4)ha29KX=Nb`0X=K?OJ>pGEcnynv(Cf)vG#XH-ZkE z-)_&}Ik_srzP{2uRq?%@J8N5KA@D5ab$RV%{=QQVU5GMK`>f>L2RtwrFTc*pQY!tYZePQ}bb-Q?>Am>0PMD3rN*->&DdOZsjb!c;qaE9_RVMTTmao5-lzh-)A!LUeaB^nbuHeW zeahm;aI#tkDdTEwnqG<%_Cm_u_a^FExYoD|)xEJr#xI<^6fK1IV?Hgo;!PDwsrfbD z)CRem;vMtrc#uykS}N*HcW3T?8a!S*yYoPjCDE_L$}shUN~}Mii)VKvTBRA}1I=*X zMyYy6t_m1L*zYJ?YN~11Lo`?!IC3C6?hM&DBHw1mOX5%!O~woI*=+kSS+KBai?$R^Q>l7 zQ^BSp0!M}S=D&FcQNAPSBPH6tk}@1*@cyxo4Ie8Ng=W1(arOx}Yj5$%WG(fj_a1MS zyqD^y8APQKDHz%vwe%*_Li0Z5E|zYW`|MjI5xqwB?@RzNkG8HoL-pcIAIe&NmPh?y zddcsz2l~RKFBUi%gX`%Z#%f!zLMT)4`(@~466x(@4Ra_a*wbIDE|jj{(O3FNylJGL zRc^W)cy9TE7%(=f=-8OMKX_(e)MCv)knwJ(i#Nad>%ic))x|All9XhIu@&*CObW(5 zUoMt3@-Q<9Oz9N$Cc&X%c{Nh9AY++G8NVWxwuJ&=7^Okv!3-OVDz30`hvC|>q28%P zJXG!wX{>(uxSIQkc`pAIDDC};sOmSh;_QU?Z8@BkD1vPnjCv^i&FyDhd zq7Am~p^%-f1N(%l8UfY3H#MlDw`?M9#5r@qP{ZNSB<`%i;oHGllG*&zFIMl)i+qb% zS=SCwV|cztmm2iFx1meQRe1N{NUWK4b4b2+XyeVbtq+^06w}trcL3Ixs63i?doypf z{prE_F0+$vy3LQU!wNnzTy*#`Xe=ODbmr)Y$tCw5lo7pFlAR!02II%7iy>;QpIjKA z&YSCPaPZ=A8r9<1E7LbybwoV|+cFeqf%-C(W`hlH0!zu_Dx67dnQm|QY7SqyPoHJ3 zAb3FTmV!6WoGwi~OP#W;lH!vt-@Y?Pw?hYJohBWOzdCnqr!kp<`(?6Ux!f2nXUcYl zsTARU4DdXX6DT*UBp)j1T4zI-+3H?%>h-c^um$;eZX1REy@-Ya@=2+g-2Qr%oH)ZrnJvO~lDgp) zbH=XF@sCVbyXk0LHXK(0MxsVf8;d=&>g&t(`m*lND}m+2u7B}YTfjXOW)yw`Scn(o zjBtnifF_qdhRGKSt}-v}n|Dy8MRP1CF?@N_7fcAbVIQ263SjI}SLOSrNZnk2b=@HC zt(pd66}@OK|}!Gk&IiW>v;S-*jMx5g8MfGA8xB+oX_@ebyMZWtJ8h$|vX>Pb2Sdby;w^j--X^fY^)%buuRv4Hps zsd4aWzIF!6RTw{AGeRs_T&;?!T1|F|nh*c7a~@0W`NkejP9x47YATTsJT!&9MsG%E z@R(xOAbMtHMuKvug!!R-*wxc064OGK_E8e0tC9?*h^8>%>}tJ6y;R%^K63hOv7RxO z+MBPw8MIbAsuf-K4&}@RD=>!l$y(gMw6DDX{M9n)`)w|q;5qRnE@DTIqZjv@)PlA? z%o-5*waqezHlNJ$P#z%#-ki*?Ep3^bAZ^$}%RXeiCAt{Jx$K$kmDuh=xCFJ`8~)}q zBJJ@Gkh_ z${eeQt$-l_`?jb@1pz?Rqg4(dI=_82^iUv;ClpCEvk8gkOnM-N&%+XLxTX*^XhH0M8u!Gx9hQq*AJ_%dzUwV=sY;h`has9v;5GpJgLnd zaNsiL7-R(Se>?KtKLtmKYuk=idyeJ#LV1u>2ZxnT>+CIFhk)^(nx)p>NsEKZn>9V< zpKy6x$24i**SN5f1VYlZb%yIrOm-k%bsc9vkiLST}clZj5aumj)iRd6|-mW4V zF_jWO3%>UmsaIRWW6*_gH1VPx_q!0)tD0#4Jcg*oQ>@5_k|?TcGWqM}whRgg*J>gL zUG)lE@QFJBPvKaCnMO@%BE5)XH@(Cg!SR5Sk0gUGdLIzs*px32v1F8PNBT6JHbKXZ zpfVzSc;CV{G?eAxwiYom0pTzp?e(~AePJ8U_d}p>E~X2?9C`=fc0)pyM%XIE7C^fI zdft}MBg>ad#7r~Wg-|{C4)uD{)>gOM)@B-aomn$QCGt_|Itbyw`l5wy5=(3jbRm%v zwY2?`ki>;5l;Jx(@-9PFMHZ;@?)%PekRX<==t?Lj zvD8*|MV3dMXV~*8`yjd?sj(RG{98DoEkNQF01k0^RiGp2Wpf|SSXMwt_hO2_%Im=>uA@M0(M|Mj3+87BkaLhj>l1Wch1R1;=?kb=PbrJ@lyA3=6*d1 z`5EaJe}xyvkqT)SU7}RvEx+#kL7Zvf?Kcw8O49Tjo1|fqc(Sf8)e`d{7qhk=I(m}# z8k)0!_b!^rHvxckfTY0K_H~*Y*xvU;0viD(-lnspX2j-nfWD(@0YYU!B!mhsf0WWL z;e5l0HVn@C3LAdKH_&`ECMAYY8|Qr>j_q{OK6K^sz05@|-ceH0Y4a6FFNczU9{gj@ zpZ_}ehoO(re;>vR{PUz5j5%rl|FMTgn!QeKK+?wDTYwQMi%?T}CW}Hv9?`w5yz?v9 z)$UKNIPAeS}6h+2_2!*ORmE6}e8bF+lK5Fqot?y6ij<9x7D#S;3xTQ>mTF<{F zP8OX_*)SAW9=#bLh%{Peu_7!J{ju1X^V~V(3>9*tQ=n`*E)@ENV8-vRnsj<8_@V_D zF$=Rd*vuOA;NfeUAoIH4J~^;-j?k~wKSaVEs^1*)x6^tQJe)A8%SPu+8 zBW;N^ce8atIlKL2OfZlt!V%5CNJ}dzDClxXTiPLX+_lhj$e(sugrlv4H<0yL6A;tJ z_N&nWVU6ZmAb%t!f3Y-NU=RcZKrkO11O$Wm`2J#O6i^5UTXP8~YX?gp=%=0p z(i}tg2teRJs~Gz*buI`m>?a_FaFMsPwYEVsLg;ROLRu(GM;$ap@~0yIyMmbxnp&}h z05R;#-`N-p4fRiN{OZBo4E2+O(nj+=7*G8~B@swVOn3jQXKdY&C@C9++iwRbBmSy` zA^-Bozub*B|Ie0^aYA$OwocYS9$i}}2`8lOZ{X+1y0#W58zh?T;ss-7@!vnZe4zic z{qI_Qa17(eCjbZX^P@{%j3NB|80_~4&WB;I_~HCOJ`jdG!$|$T{kPojk`IiLhd~8? z%JHEC%?pG4dPkFS5dL3wV@d(^IDBY~4?TTMpO`Nc{SHH~5MBX{&ad$>J;NZ-U&{nd z$T{D4vc+6f0AiBU-vjy2WsPADf2~#}TMLZeFyx}m-}h@@1-Dxz5;>X z3qV$Lgsq!15X=pRa6^EsHYk*fAP<`2M1$6D2p1b$b0oL3n>E|7g|F`BY~gN>zEbi3 zSNj+B3I6+Cjb9s63W44h&elJp|8q8fv7i4^@^Z7Z!bk5UC_d=V1LT9jcws;*;9nRV z3Pn2y^8lTGV_+}{?TvrOKp=Fy{sRMpFl*%B<@g2uiGd;iMHdQ1uZI87g+Tsc3qJ(< z&oTG}(2@TSU4D#<{vCtE{y7i$&o%m64&{bGZ+y3(H(<1EeJnA)!Z50u&d%ugV|@PW h- + + + + + + + + + + + + + image/svg+xml + + + + + + + AMOP Dispatch + Generalized Dispatch + + + + Argument + + + + Specializer + + + + Generalizer + + + + Gen. Spec. + + + + Class + + + + + Eql-Spec. + + + + + + + + + + match class-of + match + s-a-g-p + generalizer-of + + + + + Argument + + + + Specializer + + + + Class + + + + + Eql-Spec. + + + + + + + match class-of + match + + specializer-accepts-generalizer-p + + + -- 2.30.2